5 Simple Olive Oil Tasting Tips for Beginners
Want to taste olive oil like a pro? Here's how:
- Heat and mix the oil
- Smell it
- Taste it properly
- Notice the flavors
- Check the aftertaste
Key things to look for:
- Fruitiness: Overall flavor (fresh olives, grass, tomatoes)
- Bitterness: Good sign, shows healthy compounds
- Pungency: Peppery kick in your throat
Pro tip: Use dark glasses to focus on taste, not color.
Avoid oils that smell rancid, fusty, or metallic - these are red flags.
Remember: Good olive oil should taste fresh and complex, not flat or greasy. The more you taste, the better you'll get at spotting quality.
Ready to dive in? Let's explore each step in detail.
Related video from YouTube
Getting Ready to Taste
Let's set the stage for your olive oil adventure. A good setup can make or break your tasting experience. Here's how to nail it:
The Right Glass Matters
Ever wonder why pros use dark blue glasses? It's not just for show. These glasses hide the oil's color, so you focus on taste, not looks.
No blue glasses? No problem. Grab a small wine glass or a chato (that's a Spanish wine glass). Just make sure it's big enough to swirl the oil and release those yummy smells.
"Pros use dark blue glasses to avoid color bias. The oil's color doesn't actually tell you anything about taste or quality." - The Mediterranean Dish
Temperature: The Goldilocks Zone
You want your oil just right - not too hot, not too cold. Aim for room temp, about 70°F (21°C). This sweet spot lets all the flavors and aromas shine.
Here's a quick trick to warm up your oil:
- Pour about two tablespoons into your glass.
- Cup the glass in your hands, covering the top.
- Give it a gentle swirl.
This little dance helps release more aromas. It's like waking up the oil's flavors.
Create Your Tasting Space
Think of this as setting up your oil's stage:
- Pick a spot with no strong smells. You don't want anything competing with your oil.
- Good lighting is key. Natural light is best, but any bright spot works.
- If you're tasting multiple oils, line 'em up in a way that makes sense to you.
- Have some palate cleansers ready. Sliced Granny Smith apples or plain bread cubes work great.
Your Tasting Toolkit
Here's what you need:
- Tasting glasses (dark blue if you've got 'em, or small wine glasses)
- Water or sparkling water to cleanse your palate
- Those apple slices or bread cubes we talked about
- Notepads and pens for jotting down your thoughts
- 3-5 different olive oils to compare
Pro Tip: Doing a blind tasting? Number each glass and keep a secret key. It's like a mini-mystery that keeps you honest about what you really taste.
Step 1: Heat and Mix the Oil
Let's kick off our olive oil tasting adventure by waking up those flavors!
Here's what you need to do:
- Pour about two tablespoons of olive oil into your tasting glass. A blue tasting glass is ideal, but a small wine glass works too.
- Cup the glass in one hand and cover the top with your other palm.
- Gently swirl the oil for about 30 seconds.
Why all this hand-cupping and swirling? You're giving your olive oil a warm-up. This brings the oil to body temperature (around 82°F or 28°C), which helps release those hidden aromas.
"You're doing two things here: 1) holding in the aromas, and 2) warming up the oil itself." - Sarah Vachon, founder & olive oil sommelier.
The swirling isn't just for show. It's actually releasing aroma molecules, setting you up for a full sensory experience when you smell the oil.
Keep that top hand in place while you swirl. Think of it like putting a lid on a pot - you're trapping all those great smells inside until you're ready for them.
This step is all about prep work. You're setting the stage for your nose and taste buds to fully appreciate what's coming next.
If you're tasting multiple oils, warm and swirl each one right before you smell and taste it. This way, each oil is at its aromatic best when it's time for its moment in the spotlight.
Take your time, enjoy the process, and get ready to dive deeper into the world of olive oil tasting.
Step 2: Check the Smell
Time to put your nose to work. Smelling olive oil is key to understanding its quality and character.
Here's how to do it:
- Uncover the glass and bring it close to your nose
- Take a deep inhale
- Note what you smell
Good olive oil has pleasant aromas. Look for:
- Fruity notes (ripe olives or fresh grass)
- Bitter undertones
- Peppery kick
These smells often mean high-quality oil with beneficial antioxidants.
But watch out for:
- Rancid odors (crayons, putty, old peanuts)
- Fusty or musty scents
- Metallic or winey smells
These are red flags for poor quality or old oil.
"If you know what rancid, old oil tastes and smells like, you'll never get stuck again." - Alexandra Kicenik Devarenne, author of "Olive Oil: A Field Guide"
Remember, olive oil doesn't last forever. Your nose is your best tool to check if it's still good.
To get better at smelling olive oil, keep practicing. Smell different oils often and pay attention to what you notice. Over time, you'll get better at spotting the good stuff.
Next up: we'll move from smelling to tasting. Get ready to discover how these aromas turn into flavors on your tongue.
sbb-itb-4066b8e
Step 3: Take a Proper Taste
You've warmed the oil and given it a good sniff. Now it's time for the main event: tasting. This is where you'll really get to know your olive oil's personality.
Here's how to taste like a pro:
Take a small sip of oil, about a teaspoon. Don't swallow it yet! Now, here's where it gets fun (and a bit noisy). Perform the "strippaggio" - the official olive oil tasting technique:
- Open your mouth slightly
- Suck air through your teeth, making a slurping noise
- This spreads the oil across your palate
It might feel weird at first, but this technique is key. It helps release more flavors and aromas, giving you the full olive oil experience.
"Slurp a mouthful of oil while inhaling noisily, just as your mother taught you not to eat soup. Drawing air in heightens the flavor." - Eataly Guide
As you're doing this, focus on what you're tasting. Olive oil has three main flavor components:
- Fruitiness: The overall flavor of the oil. It might remind you of fresh olives, grass, or even tomatoes.
- Bitterness: You'll notice this at the back of your tongue. It's a good sign, showing healthy polyphenols.
- Pungency: The peppery kick you might feel in your throat when you swallow. Also a positive attribute.
After swirling the oil around your mouth, swallow it. Notice any lingering flavors or sensations.
Between tastings, cleanse your palate with a slice of green apple or a piece of plain bread. This resets your taste buds for the next oil.
Don't worry if you can't pick out every nuance right away. The more oils you try, the better you'll get at identifying different flavors and qualities.
In the next step, we'll dig deeper into understanding and describing those flavors you've just experienced. But for now, keep slurping and enjoy the journey of discovery!
Step 4: Notice the Flavors
Time to tune into the flavor dance on your palate. Olive oil tasting is a mini flavor adventure, with each sip revealing a world of tastes.
Here are the main flavors to look out for:
Fruitiness
This is the oil's overall flavor. It might remind you of fresh olives, but can surprise you with notes of green apple, banana, tropical fruits, fresh-cut grass, or tomato leaf.
These fruity notes often signal oil made from fresh, ripe olives. The more pronounced these flavors, the higher the quality.
Bitterness
Don't worry if you taste bitterness - it's a good sign! You'll notice it at the back of your tongue, maybe like dark roast coffee or dark chocolate.
Bitterness in olive oil shows the presence of healthy polyphenols and antioxidants. It's a sign of freshness and quality.
Pungency
This is the peppery kick you might feel in your throat when you swallow. It can range from a gentle warmth to a spicy burn.
"Feeling the burn is a sign of a great olive oil!" - The Mediterranean Dish
This peppery sensation is another indicator of high-quality oil rich in polyphenols and antioxidants.
Intensity Levels
Olive oils fall into three main intensity levels:
1. Delicate: Mild, smooth, and buttery. Great for light dishes like seafood or delicate salads.
2. Medium: Balanced bitterness and pungency with a peppery finish. Perfect for baking, salad dressings, and marinades.
3. Robust: Bold, grassy profile with high pungency and spiciness. Ideal for hearty dishes like steak or rich sauces.
As you taste, try to gauge where your oil falls on this spectrum. For instance, an Arbequina olive oil from Spain typically has a delicate profile with ripe fruit notes and low bitterness.
Green vs. Ripe Notes
The harvest time of olives greatly influences the oil's flavor profile:
- Early harvest (green olives): Intense flavors described as peppery, grassy, herbaceous, and vegetal.
- Late harvest (ripe olives): Smoother, fruitier oils with potential notes of green tea, tomato leaf, and artichoke.
As you taste, see if you can detect these nuances. Are you picking up on fresh, green notes or more mellow, ripe flavors?
Remember, there's no right or wrong when it comes to personal preference. The key is to identify what you enjoy and understand the qualities that make an olive oil great.
Keep practicing, and soon you'll be picking out these flavors like a pro. In our final step, we'll explore how to assess the aftertaste - the lingering impression that sets exceptional olive oils apart.
Step 5: Check the Aftertaste
The final step in olive oil tasting is all about the lingering impression. After swallowing, pay attention to what happens next. This reveals the oil's true character and quality.
A good extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) doesn't vanish after you swallow. Its flavors stick around, creating what's called "persistence" or aftertaste. This lingering sensation shows the oil's complexity and quality.
"It is the persistence on the palate of the sense or a number of sensations, of taste of some foods after having been ingested." - Vezorla
As the oil settles, notice:
- How the taste changes
- The strength of the aftertaste
- How long it lasts (high-quality oils can persist for minutes)
A key sign of fresh, high-quality EVOO is a peppery kick in your throat. This comes from oleocanthal, which has anti-inflammatory properties.
"Feeling the burn is a sign of a great olive oil!" - The Mediterranean Dish
But Elena Paravantes, MS, RDN, points out: "The peppery sensation should go away fairly quickly, it should not linger."
Don't mix up good bitterness with rancidity:
- Good bitterness: Clean, sharp, fades quickly
- Rancidity: Greasy, unpleasant, coats your mouth
Alexandra Kicenik Devarenne, author of "Olive Oil: A Field Guide", suggests: "If you have any doubt, take a tiny sip."
Olive oil flavor ranges from harvest-fresh to rancid. Light, air, temperature, and antioxidants affect how fast it changes.
By focusing on the aftertaste, you're getting key info about the oil's quality, freshness, and character. With practice, you'll spot the standout oils.
So take your time and let the oil tell its story. This final step is where olive oil tasting gets really interesting.
Wrap-Up
You've just taken a tasty trip through olive oil tasting. Here's a quick recap of the five steps:
- Heat and mix the oil
- Smell it
- Taste it properly
- Notice the flavors
- Check the aftertaste
The more oils you taste, the better you'll get at spotting different qualities. Don't be shy - try out lots of olive oils to expand your taste buds.
Want to go deeper? Check out Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oils (EVOO). They're cold-pressed super fast after harvesting, so you get max freshness and flavor. Here are a few to try:
- Estate Reserve Ultra Premium EVOO
- Picual Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- Coratina Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Keep this expert advice in mind:
"High-end organic extra virgin olive oil should taste like fresh herbs and fruit, with a range of profiles from delicate to complex." - Bona Furtuna
Store your olive oil right to keep it good. Cool, dark place. Use it within two years of harvest for the best taste.
Why not host an olive oil tasting party? It's a fun way to share what you've learned and try new flavors with friends. You might even find your new favorite EVOO!
Happy tasting, and enjoy those rich, complex olive oil flavors in your cooking adventures!
FAQs
What are the criteria for tasting olive oil?
When you taste olive oil, focus on three main things:
- Fruitiness: How it tastes overall - could be light or strong
- Bitterness: Shows it's fresh, you'll feel it at the back of your tongue
- Pungency: That peppery kick in your throat when you swallow
Here's something wild: A UC Davis study found that 44% of Americans actually like the taste of bad olive oil. They prefer rancid flavors! This shows why it's so important to know what good olive oil should taste like.
"If an olive oil tastes bitter, that is actually a sign that it is fresh." - Elena Paravantes, MS, RDN, Registered Dietitian Nutritionist
Don't mix up bitter with rancid. Rancid olive oil tastes like glue, wax, or crayons. Not sure? Take a tiny sip. If it's gone bad, you'll definitely notice in your mouth.
How do I taste olive oil like a pro?
Here's a quick guide to olive oil tasting:
- Grab a few different oils to compare
- Use small, dark glasses to avoid judging by color
- Pour about a tablespoon of oil, cup the glass, and cover the top
- Swirl gently and take a big sniff
- Sip a little, spread it around your mouth, and suck in some air
- Think about the fruitiness, bitterness, and pungency. Look for good stuff like herb or fruit flavors
"Olive oil tasting is similar to wine tasting: just like wines, olive oils have a very wide variety of tastes and aromas." - Eataly
Pro tip: Use green apple slices or plain water to clean your palate between oils. This helps you really taste the differences in each one.