Best Oils for Pan Seasoning: Olive Oil vs. Others
Seasoning a cast iron pan is all about creating a durable, non-stick surface by heating oil past its smoke point. The type of oil you use directly impacts the seasoning’s performance, longevity, and even flavor. Here's a quick breakdown:
- Olive Oil: Convenient and flavorful but has a lower smoke point (~375°F). Premium options like Big Horn's Ultra Premium EVOO (410°F) perform better for seasoning.
- Grapeseed Oil: Neutral flavor, high smoke point (420°F), and easy to work with.
- Canola Oil: Affordable, widely available, and effective with a 400°F smoke point.
- Flaxseed Oil: Great for initial seasoning but unsuitable for high heat (225°F smoke point).
- Lard/Bacon Grease: Traditional and effective but can spoil if not used frequently.
Quick Comparison
| Oil Type | Smoke Point (°F) | Flavor | Best For | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Olive Oil | 375–410 | Fruity | Moderate heat seasoning | Moderate |
| Grapeseed Oil | 420 | Neutral | High heat seasoning | Moderate |
| Canola Oil | 400 | Neutral | Everyday seasoning | Low |
| Flaxseed Oil | 225 | Nutty | Initial seasoning layers | High |
| Lard/Bacon Grease | 325–370 | Savory | Durable seasoning, frequent use | Low |
The best choice depends on your cooking style, budget, and priorities. For high heat, grapeseed or avocado oil works well. For flavor and moderate heat, olive oil is a solid option, especially premium varieties like Big Horn EVOO. If you're restoring old pans, flaxseed oil is ideal for the first layer. Regular maintenance with affordable options like canola oil ensures long-lasting performance.
Seasoning Cast Iron (Flaxseed vs. Old School methods)
Olive Oil for Pan Seasoning
Olive oil is a kitchen essential, making it a convenient option for seasoning cast iron pans. Its properties make it particularly useful for gradual seasoning applications, though it has its limitations.
Benefits of Olive Oil
Extra virgin olive oil brings more to the table than just its seasoning potential. Its subtle, fruity flavor can enhance the taste of foods cooked in a seasoned pan. With about 73% monounsaturated fat, it’s also a heart-healthy choice that offers antioxidants to support stability during moderate-heat cooking. For those who care about sustainable practices, its eco-friendly sourcing adds another layer of appeal.
Lodge, a trusted name in cast iron cookware, highlights olive oil as a good option for everyday cooking and incremental seasoning at moderate temperatures. While it may not be the best choice for the initial high-heat seasoning process, regular use can help build up a durable seasoning layer over time.
Drawbacks of Olive Oil
One of olive oil’s key limitations is its relatively low smoke point, which is around 375°F (191°C). Lower-grade olive oils may burn at even lower temperatures, leading to uneven seasoning. Additionally, olive oil doesn’t have the longest shelf life - it’s best used within nine months of its crush date to maintain quality.
"If your olive oil is burning when you bake with it, you're using a low grade olive oil!" - Big Horn Olive Oil
When olive oil exceeds its smoke point, it can produce harmful compounds, which not only affect your health but also interfere with creating a smooth, durable seasoning layer. However, some premium options, like Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium EVOO, offer solutions to these challenges.
Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium EVOO
Big Horn Olive Oil has tackled many of olive oil’s traditional shortcomings with its Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil line. These oils boast a smoke point of 410°F or higher, making them a better fit for seasoning applications that require higher heat.
Freshness is a priority for Big Horn, as they ship their oils within 1–3 months of harvest to ensure peak quality. They select only the top 5% of olives for production, resulting in oils rich in antioxidant biophenols. These antioxidants not only improve stability during heating but also extend the oil's shelf life. This makes it a practical and eco-conscious choice, as it reduces the need for frequent re-seasoning.
Big Horn’s commitment to quality has earned them international accolades, and customer reviews reflect their reputation for excellence:
"Having never tasted quality balsamics and olive oils, I had no idea what was in store when I happened upon this pretty storefront in Reno. What an experience!" - Cathy R., Google Review
"The very healthiest oils you can buy." - LakeTahoeGem, Google Review (Local Guide)
Starting at $8.99, their Ultra Premium EVOO varieties, including Picual, Arbequina, and Cobrançosa, offer premium quality at an accessible price. For cast iron enthusiasts who value both seasoning performance and cooking quality, Big Horn Olive Oil is a standout choice. Up next, we’ll explore other oils commonly used for seasoning.
Other Oils for Pan Seasoning
If olive oil isn’t your go-to, there are plenty of other options to consider. Each type of oil has its own strengths and drawbacks when it comes to seasoning your pans.
Grapeseed Oil
Grapeseed oil is a popular choice because it can handle high heat, with a smoke point of about 420°F. Its neutral flavor won’t interfere with the taste of your food, and its light texture makes it easy to work with. Plus, it’s often praised for its health benefits, adding to its appeal.
Canola Oil
Canola oil is a reliable option for everyday seasoning. With a moderate smoke point of around 400°F, it’s affordable and widely available, making it a practical choice for most kitchens.
Flaxseed Oil
Flaxseed oil is known for creating a tough, long-lasting seasoning layer, which makes it a favorite for restoring older cookware. However, its low smoke point - approximately 225°F - means it’s better suited for seasoning rather than high-heat cooking.
Lard and Bacon Grease
For a more traditional approach, lard and bacon grease are excellent at forming a durable seasoning layer while adding a savory touch to your cookware. The downside? They can go rancid if not used regularly or stored correctly. On the other hand, plant-based oils are often seen as a more environmentally friendly option and are better suited for those following vegetarian or vegan diets.
sbb-itb-4066b8e
Oil Comparison: Smoke Points, Flavor, and Uses
Understanding the distinct qualities of different oils can help you choose the best one for seasoning and cooking.
Oil Comparison Table
| Oil Type | Smoke Point (°F) | Flavor Profile | Suitability for Seasoning | Suitability for Cooking |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avocado Oil | 520 | Neutral | Excellent | Excellent |
| Grapeseed Oil | 420 | Light, neutral | Excellent | Excellent |
| Sunflower Oil | 440 | Neutral | Excellent | Excellent |
| Peanut Oil | 450 | Neutral | Excellent | Excellent |
| Canola Oil | 400 | Neutral | Excellent | Excellent |
| Vegetable Oil | 400 | Neutral | Good | Good |
| Extra Virgin Olive Oil | 375–410+ | Fruity, robust | Fair to Good | Good (low/medium heat) |
| Lard | 370 | Rich, savory | Good (if used often) | Good |
| Bacon Grease | 325 | Smoky, savory | Good (if used often) | Good |
| Flaxseed Oil | 225 | Nutty | Excellent (initial only) | Poor |
This table highlights how various oils perform in seasoning and cooking, helping you make informed choices for your kitchen.
Choosing the Right Oil for Seasoning
The smoke point of an oil is a key factor when seasoning cookware. Oils with higher smoke points can endure the high heat required to create a durable, nonstick layer. On the flip side, oils with low smoke points may break down under heat, leaving behind a sticky residue instead of a smooth finish.
For example, avocado oil is a top pick for seasoning due to its impressive 520°F smoke point. It can handle high temperatures without breaking down, and its neutral flavor ensures your food’s natural taste remains intact. While Extra Virgin Olive Oil is popular for its robust flavor, its smoke point varies - standard options hover around 375°F, while premium varieties like Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium EVOO can reach 410°F or more.
Flaxseed oil, with its nutty flavor and 225°F smoke point, is best suited for the initial seasoning layer only. It creates a solid base but isn’t ideal for ongoing use due to its low heat tolerance.
Neutral Oils and Animal-Based Options
Neutral oils like grapeseed, canola, and vegetable oil are versatile choices. They withstand high heat, won’t interfere with your food’s flavor, and store well. This is why brands like Lodge, a leading cast iron cookware manufacturer, use soy-based vegetable oil to pre-season their pans - it’s durable, safe, and effective.
For those who prefer animal-based options, lard and bacon grease provide a savory finish. However, they can turn rancid if not used frequently, making them less practical for some kitchens.
Eco-Friendly Oil Selection
When choosing oils for pan seasoning, it’s worth thinking beyond just smoke points and flavors. The environmental impact of your selection matters too. Opting for eco-conscious oils not only enhances your cooking but also supports practices that are kinder to the planet.
Look for certifications like USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Fair Trade when shopping. These labels signal that the oils were produced responsibly, whether through pesticide-free farming or ethical labor practices. Such standards ensure high-quality oils while helping to reduce the environmental footprint.
Locally sourced oils are another excellent choice. They cut down on transportation emissions and support regional agriculture. For instance, California olive oils are a great example - they’re fresh, high-quality, and reduce the environmental costs associated with long-distance shipping. Brands like Big Horn Olive Oil demonstrate how sustainability and premium production can go hand in hand.
It’s also worth understanding how different oils affect the environment. Olive oil, for example, can require significant water during production, though organic farming methods can help address this. Meanwhile, canola and grapeseed oils often come from large-scale operations that might contribute to habitat loss unless they’re organically produced. On the other hand, flaxseed oil has a smaller environmental footprint but is less versatile in the kitchen.
Packaging plays a role too. Choose oils in glass bottles instead of plastic for better recyclability, and buy only what you need to avoid waste. Storing oils properly - in cool, dark places - also extends their shelf life and prevents spoilage.
Before committing to a brand, take a moment to research their sustainability claims. Trustworthy companies will provide clear details about their farming practices, sourcing, and certifications. Be cautious of vague marketing terms that lack third-party verification.
To make an eco-friendly choice, prioritize organic oils produced locally and packaged in recyclable materials. California olive oils or organic canola and grapeseed oils from regional producers are excellent options. Plus, you won’t have to compromise on performance - sustainably produced oils work just as well as conventional ones for seasoning and cooking. By choosing eco-friendly oils, you can season your pans effectively while doing your part for the environment.
Choosing the Right Oil for Pan Seasoning
Picking the right oil for seasoning your pan comes down to your priorities and the oil’s key characteristics. The most important factor? The smoke point. Oils with smoke points above 400°F are perfect because they create a tough, long-lasting seasoning layer that holds up to high-heat cooking and frequent use. Beyond that, you’ll want to weigh performance, health considerations, and cost.
For durability and performance, canola oil and grapeseed oil are excellent choices. Lodge, a trusted name in cast iron cookware, specifically recommends vegetable oil, melted shortening, or canola oil. Why? They’re affordable, widely available, effective, and have high smoke points, making them ideal for seasoning. Organic canola oil, with its 400°F smoke point, is a budget-friendly and reliable option.
If health benefits are a priority, you don’t have to sacrifice quality. For example, Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium EVOO boasts a smoke point of 410°F or higher and is rich in antioxidant biophenols, which go above and beyond the standard for extra virgin olive oil. These qualities make it a great choice for those looking to combine health-conscious cooking with effective pan seasoning.
When it comes to budget and availability, canola oil offers a fantastic balance of cost and performance for regular seasoning upkeep. If you’re willing to splurge, avocado oil delivers top-notch results with its high smoke point, making it ideal for frequent high-temperature cooking. On the other hand, flaxseed oil is best reserved for initial seasoning rather than ongoing maintenance. Your cooking style matters, too - if you often sear at high temperatures, avocado oil might be worth the investment. For moderate-heat cooking with a neutral flavor, grapeseed oil is a versatile pick. Traditionalists might prefer lard, which creates a durable, flavorful surface but needs regular use to avoid turning rancid.
To make the best choice, think about your cookware, how often you cook, your typical cooking temperatures, and whether you prioritize health, environmental impact, or overall performance. The science behind seasoning lies in how oils polymerize under high heat to form that durable, nonstick layer.
Ultimately, consistency is more important than finding the “perfect” oil. Regular maintenance with a reliable oil will always outperform sporadic seasoning with a premium option. Start with accessible choices like canola or grapeseed oil, and as you get into the habit, you can experiment with higher-end oils to fine-tune your seasoning routine.
FAQs
What makes olive oil a good choice for seasoning a cast iron pan, and how does it compare to other oils?
When it comes to seasoning a cast iron pan, high-quality extra virgin olive oil is an excellent choice. One of its standout features is its high smoke point, typically around 410°F or more for premium options. This makes it ideal for building a durable, non-stick seasoning layer. Plus, its natural antioxidants can help extend the life of your cookware.
Unlike some other oils, olive oil offers versatility and is a more environmentally friendly option. It's also packed with healthy fats, making it a smart pick for kitchen use. While oils like flaxseed or vegetable oil are often used for seasoning, olive oil shines due to its quality, freshness, and nutritional value, especially when sourced from reputable providers specializing in Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil.
Why does the smoke point of an oil matter for seasoning a pan, and which oils work best?
When it comes to seasoning a pan, the smoke point of an oil plays a key role. This is the temperature where the oil starts to break down, producing smoke and losing its ability to create that durable, non-stick surface you’re aiming for. Opting for an oil with a higher smoke point helps ensure a solid seasoning layer without introducing any off flavors.
For this purpose, high-quality oils, such as ultra-premium extra virgin olive oil, are a solid choice. With a smoke point of around 410°F, they strike a great balance between performance and longevity. Plus, their natural properties contribute to extending the life of your cookware. Always go for fresh, high-quality oils to achieve the best results.
What should I look for in an eco-friendly and sustainable oil for pan seasoning?
When selecting an environmentally conscious oil for pan seasoning, it's important to prioritize quality and freshness. Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO), such as those from Big Horn Olive Oil, stands out as a great choice. These oils are known for their sustainable harvesting practices and commitment to high standards. Freshness plays a crucial role - opt for oils bottled soon after harvest to guarantee top-notch quality while also supporting eco-friendly practices. Look for producers who emphasize transparency and environmentally responsible methods in their production process.