Sensory Evaluation of Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Sensory evaluation is essential for determining the quality of extra virgin olive oil (EVOO). Experts assess oils based on positive traits (like fruity, bitter, and pungent flavors) and defects (such as rancidity or mustiness). For an oil to qualify as extra virgin, it must have no detectable flaws and a fruity score greater than zero. The International Olive Council (IOC) provides global standards to ensure consistent quality.

Key Points:

• Positive Traits: Fruity, bitter, pungent.
• Common Defects: Rancid, musty, winey, fusty.
• Grading System: Oils are scored on a 10-point scale.
• Testing Methods: Includes sensory panel evaluations and lab tests for chemical quality.
• Tasting Process: Involves aroma, taste, and texture analysis in controlled environments.

Sensory testing, combined with lab analysis, ensures EVOO quality and helps producers maintain consistency while educating consumers about olive oil standards.

Main Sensory Properties of EVOO

Desired Flavor Traits

The quality of extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) is judged based on three key positive traits: fruitiness, bitterness, and pungency. Fruitiness includes aromas and flavors ranging from green to ripe. Bitterness is detected on the sides of the tongue, while pungency creates a sharp, peppery sensation in the throat . Professional tasters rely on standardized scales to ensure consistent evaluations of these traits. While these positive attributes highlight quality, defects point to issues in processing or storage.

Common Oil Defects

EVOO can suffer from several common defects, which impact its quality:

The first three defects typically arise from poor fruit handling, while rancidity occurs during storage . In Spain, sensory defects are common, with 45–55% of olive oil production classified as Virgin or Lampante grade . These defects are factored into professional scoring systems used to evaluate oil quality.

Rating Systems and Terms

Standardized rating systems help professionals compare oils by measuring both positive traits and defects. These systems give tasters a shared vocabulary for evaluation.

Positive attributes include:

• Almond
• Apple
• Artichoke
• Green grass
• Spicy notes

Negative traits include:

• Earthy
• Metallic
• Flat
• Muddy
• Wine-vinegar

Oils with strong defect scores are categorized as lampante and must be refined before they are safe for consumption .

Expert Tasting Methods

Tasting Room Setup

The International Olive Council (IOC) has set clear guidelines for creating a controlled environment for evaluating extra virgin olive oil (EVOO). These standards ensure a consistent and unbiased sensory analysis. A tasting room must be free of odors and equipped with specific tools to limit external distractions.

Here’s what a professional tasting setup requires:

Before tasting sessions, professional tasters must follow strict preparation rules. This includes avoiding coffee, food, and smoking to preserve their sensory sensitivity . These measures help maintain consistency and reliability across tasting panels.

Tasting Steps

Once the environment is ready, tasters follow a detailed four-step process to evaluate the oil’s qualities. This structured method, first outlined by Camurati and colleagues in 1985, ensures every aspect of the oil is assessed thoroughly .

1. Visual Assessment

Although color doesn’t indicate quality, tasters check the oil’s clarity and texture. Blue-tinted glasses are used to block color bias while concentrating the aroma .

2. Aroma Evaluation

The glass is warmed to 82°F to release volatile compounds. Tasters swirl the oil and take deep inhalations to assess the scent’s intensity and character .

3. Taste Analysis

A specific tasting technique, called "slurping", is used to evaluate flavor:

• Sip a small amount of oil
• Introduce air to emulsify the oil
• Spread it across the mouth to detect retro-nasal aromas and bitterness

4. Texture and Pungency Assessment

In the final step, tasters swallow a small amount to gauge its pungency in the throat. Between samples, green apple and water are used to cleanse the palate, keeping taste sensitivity sharp .

The IOC oversees sensory panels worldwide, ensuring evaluations are consistent. Final scores are based on combined results from multiple certified tasters, blending sensory feedback with lab data to determine the oil’s quality .

Professional Guide to Extra Virgin Olive Oil Tasting

sbb-itb-4066b8e

Lab Tests vs. Taste Tests

While sensory tests evaluate flavor and aroma, lab analyses provide objective data about olive oil quality.

Key Lab Measurements

Chemical analysis plays a major role in assessing extra virgin olive oil (EVOO). Laboratories follow International Olive Council (IOC) standards to measure specific indicators of quality and purity. Some of the most important tests include:

While there are over 25 parameters in the standards, only 7–9 are used to determine the quality grade. The rest focus on verifying the oil's authenticity and origin . However, these chemical tests don't reveal much about the oil's flavor or aroma.

Limitations of Lab Tests

Lab tests provide hard data but can't account for subtle taste and aroma differences. For instance, a UC Davis study showed that 73% of top-selling imported EVOO brands passed chemical tests but failed sensory evaluations .

Recent advancements, like chemometric models and volatile compound analysis, are helping bridge this gap. Projects like OLEUM, which achieved a 98.5% success rate, combine lab and sensory methods to improve accuracy .

"The new method must be considered an addition to what we already have, which is the panel test. The panel test has been crucial in improving the products ending up on the shelves."

Industry Uses of Sensory Testing

Sensory testing, combined with lab evaluations, plays a key role in ensuring product quality, refining blending processes, and educating consumers about olive oil.

Quality Control Standards

Sensory evaluation is a cornerstone of olive oil quality control. By integrating tasting panels with lab tests, producers can classify oils and maintain consistency. For example, a study of 305 virgin olive oil samples revealed that combining instrumental screening tools with sensory panel assessments led to an 84% reliable classification rate for virgin olive oils . This approach has also streamlined the process, reducing the number of samples requiring panel reviews to less than one-third. This allows experts to focus on cases needing closer attention .

Oil Blending Methods

Sensory testing is essential for creating consistent flavor profiles in oil blending. In Italy, where much of the production is concentrated in the south, the Coratina cultivar makes up about 40% of the country’s total olive oil production . Modern blending methods incorporate both sensory and chemical analyses, particularly focusing on phenolic compounds that affect the flavor and nutritional properties of extra virgin olive oil . This method helps master blenders maintain a steady and recognizable taste.

Consumer Training

Professional tasting panels also play a role in educating consumers by using standardized evaluation methods. Organizations like the International Olive Council (IOC) and USDA include both sensory and chemical analyses in their quality standards . Producers employ various training techniques to help consumers make informed choices:

The OLEUM project highlights the power of systematic sensory evaluation, achieving a 98.5% classification accuracy by using a "decision tree" system and strict quality control protocols .

Summary

Main Points

Sensory evaluation, following International Olive Council (IOC) standards, assesses the quality of extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) by combining sensory and chemical tests . Professional tasting panels score oils based on positive traits like fruity, bitter, and pungent flavors, while identifying defects. Common defects that disqualify oils include:

• Fusty or muddy sediment: Caused by fermentation in poorly stored olives.
• Musty notes: Resulting from exposure to humidity.
• Winey flavors: Linked to unclean equipment.
• Rancidity: From oxidation over time.

By blending sensory panel results with laboratory data, producers create a reliable system for classifying EVOO, ensuring consistent standards . Industry leaders rely on this structured approach.

Big Horn Olive Oil Quality Standards

Big Horn Olive Oil adopts IOC-aligned protocols to maintain its ultra-premium EVOO quality. Their methods reflect the rigorous practices outlined above, with strict quality controls at every production stage.

Related Blog Posts

• 5 Steps to Evaluate Olive Oil Mouthfeel
• Checklist for Olive Oil Sensory Evaluation
• Olive Oil Texture vs. Flavor: Key Differences
• EVOO Testing Standards Explained