7 Mistakes When Cooking With Olive Oil

Want to get the best out of olive oil? Avoid these 7 common mistakes:

1. Overheating the oil: High-quality olive oil can handle heat up to 410°F, but overheating destroys nutrients and flavor.
2. Choosing the wrong type: Match the oil grade (e.g., Extra Virgin, Light) to your cooking method and temperature.
3. Improper storage: Keep olive oil in a cool, dark place, away from light, heat, and air to prevent spoilage.
4. Using expired oil: Check the crush date and use within 9 months for optimal taste and quality.
5. Adding oil at the wrong time: Timing matters - preheat for cooking, drizzle fresh for finishing.
6. Believing color myths: Color doesn’t indicate quality; focus on freshness, smoke point, and flavor.
7. Using too much or too little: Measure carefully to avoid greasy dishes or uneven cooking.

Quick Tip: Store olive oil in dark containers, buy small amounts, and always check the label for crush dates to enjoy its full flavor and benefits.

The 5 WORST Olive Oil Mistakes and How To Avoid Them!

1. Heating Oil Too Hot

Overheating olive oil can ruin its quality. High-quality extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) has a smoke point of 410°F or higher, making it suitable for most cooking methods. However, pushing it past this limit can cause:

• Breakdown of healthy compounds
• Unpleasant flavors
• Loss of nutrients

"You can't cook with olive oil" Wrong! A high-quality olive oil will have a high smoke point. If your olive oil is burning when you bake with it, you're using a low grade olive oil!" - Big Horn Olive Oil

Temperature Guidelines

Big Horn Olive Oil’s Ultra Premium EVOOs are specially crafted for high-temperature cooking, with smoke points of 410°F or higher. This ensures you can use them for various methods without sacrificing flavor or nutrition.

Watch for signs of overheating, such as:

• Smoke rising from the pan
• Strong, unpleasant smells
• Oil becoming unusually thin
• Darkened oil color

To avoid these issues, heat your pan slowly and add oil only when it’s time to cook.

2. Picking the Wrong Oil Type

Once you've got temperature control sorted, the next step is choosing the right oil for your cooking.

Using the wrong oil often comes down to not matching its properties - like smoke point and flavor - to the cooking method.

Olive Oil Grades

The type of olive oil you use matters. Each grade has its own uses and heat tolerance:

Balancing Heat and Flavor

When picking olive oil, think about both its heat tolerance and how its flavor will influence your dish. A bold EVOO can enhance your recipe, but it won't overpower the other ingredients if chosen wisely.

What to Look For

To make sure you're using the best oil:

• Check the crush date and smoke point on the label.
• Choose an oil that fits your cooking style - whether you're frying, baking, or sautéing.

For example, Big Horn Olive Oil's Ultra Premium EVOO is perfect for high-heat cooking, offering excellent flavor and retaining nutrients.

Up next: how to store your olive oil to keep it fresh and effective.

3. Poor Storage Methods

Storing olive oil the right way is key to keeping it fresh and preventing it from going bad. If stored incorrectly, olive oil can lose its quality and flavor faster than expected.

Factors That Affect Olive Oil Quality

Several elements can cause olive oil to degrade:

• Light exposure: UV rays can break down important compounds in the oil.
• Heat: High temperatures speed up the oxidation process.
• Air contact: Oxygen exposure can lead to rancidity.

How to Store Olive Oil

To keep your olive oil fresh, follow these tips:

• Keep it in a cool, dark cabinet, away from heat sources like the stove.
• Use dark-tinted bottles to block UV rays.
• Store it in the original container with a tight-fitting cap to limit air exposure.

"For optimal taste, consume your oil promptly after opening." - The UC Davis Olive Center

Best Practices for Storage

Buy Smart, Use Smart

Buying the right amount of olive oil is just as important as storing it correctly. Choose quantities you’ll use within a few months. Brands like Big Horn Olive Oil offer Ultra Premium EVOO in sizes that help maintain freshness for typical household needs.

Warning Signs of Poor Storage

If your olive oil smells rancid or tastes off, it’s likely been stored improperly and has started to degrade.

Up next, we’ll cover how to avoid mistakes when adding olive oil during cooking.

4. Using Expired Olive Oil

Expired olive oil not only loses its flavor but also its nutritional value. Here’s how to identify and avoid using oil that's past its prime.

How to Spot Expired Olive Oil

Fresh olive oil has a fruity scent and a smooth, pleasant taste. If your olive oil shows any of these signs, it’s likely expired:

• A rancid or stale odor
• A sour or overly bitter taste
• A dull, lifeless color instead of its usual bright tone
• A thicker or stickier texture than normal

Shelf Life: What You Need to Know

The crush date is your best guide to olive oil freshness. For optimal taste and quality, aim to use it within 9 months of that date. Here's a quick breakdown:

Tips to Keep Your Olive Oil Fresh

Follow these steps to make the most of your olive oil and prevent spoilage:

• Always check the crush date before buying.
• Buy a bottle size that matches how often you cook.
• Write down the date you open each bottle.
• Use older bottles first by rotating your stock.
• Test the oil’s freshness before using it.

"For the best tasting experience, we recommend consumption within 9 months of the olive oil crush date." - The UC Davis Olive Center

sbb-itb-4066b8e

5. Wrong Timing When Adding Oil

When you add olive oil during cooking can make a big difference in flavor and results. Here's how to time it right for different cooking methods.

Sautéing and Pan Frying

For these methods, always preheat your pan with the oil before adding ingredients. Extra virgin olive oil can handle heat up to 410°F, making it a great choice for most stovetop cooking.

Roasting Techniques

When roasting, you have two good options for adding oil:

Finishing Dishes

For a flavor boost, drizzle fresh olive oil right before serving. Use this on hot soups, stews, grilled meats, roasted veggies, fresh salads, or warm pasta. Adding it at this stage keeps its taste and aroma intact.

Temperature Tips

Always preheat your pan or oven to the desired temperature before adding food coated with oil. This prevents the oil from being exposed to high heat for too long. Keep temperatures below 410°F when using extra virgin olive oil.

Mistakes to Watch For

Skipping a final drizzle can rob your dish of olive oil's rich flavor and aroma. Timing matters as much as choosing and storing your olive oil, ensuring every dish gets the full benefit of its taste and quality.

6. Color Myths and Oil Quality

The color of olive oil - whether it's golden yellow or deep green - doesn't determine its quality. Instead, the oil's grade and taste depend on other, more important factors.

What Actually Matters

Let's move past the color myth and focus on measurable factors that affect olive oil quality:

The Truth About Smoke Points

A high smoke point means the oil can handle a variety of cooking methods. High-quality extra virgin olive oils are stable at higher temperatures, making them a great choice for everything from sautéing to baking.

"You can't cook with olive oil" - Not true! A good olive oil will have a high smoke point. If your oil burns while cooking, you're probably using a low-grade product.

Tips for Smarter Shopping

When buying olive oil, keep these tips in mind:

• Choose a size you can use up before the oil loses freshness.
• Look for smoke point ratings to match your cooking needs.
• Check the label for production details like the crush date.

The Role of Storage

How you store olive oil matters more than its color. To preserve quality, keep it in an airtight container away from light at room temperature. Even the best olive oil won't last forever - its quality degrades over time, no matter how it looks.

Up next, learn how using the wrong amount of oil can ruin even the highest-quality olive oil.

7. Incorrect Oil Amounts

Using the right amount of olive oil is just as important as adding it at the right time. Too much oil can make your dish greasy and lead to waste, while too little can cause food to stick or cook unevenly. To avoid these issues, measure your oil carefully based on the recipe and cooking method. Also, pick a container size that matches how often you cook, and always check the crush date. Using olive oil within 9 months helps keep its flavor fresh and reduces waste.

Olive Oil Types and Uses

Understanding olive oil types can help you avoid cooking mishaps. Higher-quality olive oils generally have higher smoke points, making them suitable for a range of cooking techniques. This ties into earlier tips about common cooking mistakes and helps you make better choices in the kitchen.

"You can't cook with olive oil" Wrong! A high-quality olive oil will have a high smoke point. If your olive oil is burning when you bake with it, you're using a low grade olive oil!" - Big Horn Olive Oil

Picking the right olive oil not only avoids common cooking errors but also improves the results of any dish. For example, Ultra Premium EVOOs, with smoke points of 410°F or higher, are ideal for high-heat cooking.

Here’s a quick guide for selecting olive oil based on your cooking needs:

• High-heat (400°F or more): Ultra Premium EVOO
• Medium-heat (350–400°F): Extra Virgin or Virgin Olive Oil
• Low-heat (below 350°F): Any type works
• Raw uses (like dressings): Ultra Premium EVOO for the best flavor

When shopping, check for clear crush dates and buy sizes you’ll use within a few months to keep the oil fresh.

Summary

Mastering olive oil in cooking comes down to three key steps: choosing the right oil, storing it correctly, and using the right temperatures. Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO), with smoke points above 410°F, is perfect for a variety of cooking methods without worrying about burning or losing quality.

"A high-quality olive oil will have a high smoke point. If your olive oil is burning when you bake with it, you're using a low grade olive oil!" - Big Horn Olive Oil

To get the most out of your olive oil:

• Keep it in a cool, dark spot away from heat
• Check the crush date and use it within 9 months
• Buy only what you can finish in a few months after opening
• Choose an oil that matches your cooking temperature needs

Following these steps helps you make the most of olive oil's flavor and benefits. Big Horn Olive Oil’s Ultra Premium EVOOs are an excellent choice for everything from high-heat cooking to adding a finishing touch.

Want to improve your cooking and avoid common olive oil pitfalls? Check out Big Horn Olive Oil for their range of Ultra Premium EVOOs.

Related posts

• Top 7 Olive Oil Tips for Festive Mediterranean Cooking
• How Olive Oil Flavor Changes Over Time
• Best Temperatures for Storing Olive Oil
• Top 7 Label Terms for Olive Oil Buyers